Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Marina Brungardt's avatar

I also wonder about some of the emergence arguments generally with consciousness. Like ok a bunch of proto-loud children can create a choir that is in fact loud, but there it’s more of the same, not an entirely new sort of emergence. Obviously I’m compressing the arguments, but I don’t see that they don’t reduce to those terms. But I also think it helps to have a non-materialist, realist approach when getting at this. I mean unless you’re a Human Being Being Humean. Which I guess some are.

Max Harden's avatar

Excellent stuff! I think “talking” with the AI about Quine is close to playing tennis with a wall, but I suppose the alternative to these uses of ordinary language is the AI people coming up with more silly words and phrases (which is probably worse).

10 more comments...

Ready for more?