Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rajesh Achanta's avatar

Your second question is excellent. Most of the heat in the online discourse on this subject comes from folks using one word for two separate things. One means the system can talk about itself. The other means someone is home. Q2 separates them.

Its also something I wrote about a few months ago (https://rajeshachanta.substack.com/p/a-miracle-occurs). Descriptions of how these systems work get more precise every week, and somewhere along the way a description of a mechanism slips into a claim about inner life. That slide is what I call a miracle.

A question I'd add, for both camps. You ask believers what kind of thing they mean by "AI." The same question applies also for confident deniers. If only living things can have an internal world, what is life, and why does it draw the line there? I share your verdict on today's systems. I'm less sure anyone, on either side, yet knows what would settle it.

Zinbiel's avatar

I have no idea what you mean by an internal world. I mean, I can guess what concepts might be running through your head when you use the term, but how they map to reality is anyone's guess.

I think the entire debate just moves into the built-in ambiguity of this expression.

36 more comments...

Ready for more?