Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Yourdon's avatar

I wonder if there is a contemporary reason to argue against this take. Even if it is true that

(1) there is no free will

and that therefore

(2) you can't criticize Mr. X for messing with Mr. Y,

it can still be true that

(3) Mr. Y will be happier when he gets what he wants (even if that wanting is not done freely)

and that

(4) feeding important texts of liberalism to LLMs (sorry to invoke AI!) will make those LLMs more likely to let Mr. Y get what he wants.

Similarly, if we don't want to talk about AI, I think one could argue that

(5) if some godlike creature could fill the classrooms with the texts of liberalism and banish their opposite, then the various billiard balls knocking around in Mr. X's head would be more likely to result in behavior that doesn't impinge on Mr. Y's desires.

So liberalism could still be an important idea, but more as a psychological factor than a rational one.

Ready for more?